Fighter Sweep
  • Home
  • Military Aviation
  • Air Force
  • Navy
  • Spec Ops
  • Expert Analysis
  • Careers
  • Photos
Home Previous Post Next Post
Follow @fightersweep

High Threat Close Air Support (CAS): Myth or Reality?

July 2, 2016
FighterSweep Staff 9 Comments Expert Analysis

In a recent War on the Rocks article by Col. Mike “Starbaby” Pietrucha, the author argues that using airpower in a high threat Close Air Support role is a myth and not as practical as using land based or sea based precision artillery.

If you are the Air Force, what do you do when you your primary CAS platform, the A-10 Warthog, has been put on the chopping block by 2021, you have no real replacement, and the F-35 stealth savior can’t seem to get here on time?

Answer: Maybe you should look more definitively at your requirements against reality.

Pietrucha writes: “In a presumed environment where the air defenses are too lethal for the A-10 to survive, wouldn’t the F-35 be a better alternative? The question itself highlights a persistent trend in Air Force concept development — a mythical set of conditions that is highly unlikely, fundamentally not credible, based on a misunderstanding of the air threat, or, in this case, all three.”

Pietrucha notes that no aircraft, stealth or not, can survive a high threat CAS environment.  The mythical idea that the F-35 will simply be able to loiter in and around the target area is simply that:  a myth.  Radar systems such as the SA-22 render stealth characterstics mute while heat exhaust from any engine allows for detection in the IR environment.

The other question mentioned: is high threat CAS really something that USAF airpower will be faced with?  Not according to Pietrucha.  The only two threats that hold a high threat capability, China and Russia, are likely to never see a demand for US airpower for such a mission due to impractical circumstances.

One must remember that CAS is a mission and not simply a platform.  Future CAS efforts will likely come from a variety of sources:  drones (all categories), stealth, and conventional air power.  Maybe a greater concern should center on integration of these multitude of forces in the event of the mythical high threat scenario?

You can read Pietrucha’s full article here

Top photo courtesy www.armyrecognition.com 

Related Posts

  • Watch: See what it’s like to be on the receiving end of an A-10 Warthog strafing runWatch: See what it’s like to be on the receiving end of an A-10 Warthog strafing run
  • The Pic of the Day: A B-2 with a viewThe Pic of the Day: A B-2 with a view
  • The Pic of the Day: F-35 takes off from Nellis Air Force BaseThe Pic of the Day: F-35 takes off from Nellis Air Force Base
  • The Pic of the Day: The massive size of the vertical stabilizer on a B-52H StratofortressThe Pic of the Day: The massive size of the vertical stabilizer on a B-52H Stratofortress
  • The Pic of the Day: Giants in the mistThe Pic of the Day: Giants in the mist

Find Us on Facebook

FighterSweep.com

Sign Up
for the Newsletter

What’s Hot

  • July 3, 2022

    Russians Are Accidentally Flying Their Jets Into the Ground to Avoid Being Shot Down

  • July 5, 2022

    Female Air Force Special Tactics Officer First to Earn Scarlet Beret

  • July 4, 2022

    Spain Will Replace F/A-18 Hornets with NATO Eurofighter in $2.15 Billion Deal

Follow Us

Facebook Twitter Twitter

Recent Comments

  • Lars Dirch Sørensen This didn't age well.
  • Speir Mor Media Amazing history and pride in the old B-52! And that’s one hell of a range. [...]
  • disqus_lkVjMrnsGt As an 8th grader in 1960 I first became acquainted with the 1952 Washington [...]
  • SWS Irrational fears and misinformation is not a reason to get a waiver from a [...]

© Copyright 2022 SOFREP Media Group. All Rights Reserved.

  • Privacy Policy
  • Terms of Use
  • Advertisers